Biden is willing to forgive $10,000 in student loans per borrower — what it means for your budget, credit score and tax bill

If $10,000 disappears from your student debt, you might want to celebrate.

It’s a question millions of student loan holders could soon face if President Joe Biden implements a controversial plan to write off $10,000 in federal student loan debt per borrower with executive action. .

The details of this answer will affect a borrower’s daily budget, credit score and potentially taxes too, according to financial experts.

The Biden administration is reportedly considering a plan to forgive $10,000 of federal student loan debt per borrower for people earning up to $150,000 and married couples filing jointly who earn up to $300,000, the Washington said. Post, citing sources familiar with the discussions.

Proponents say borrowers badly need relief from a crisis linked to soaring education costs that have strained family budgets.

Americans have about $1.6 trillion in student loan debt, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Payments on loans held by the federal government have been on pause since the start of the pandemic in March 2020.

On Wednesday, the administration canceled the federal student loan debt of more than 560,000 defrauded borrowers who attended the now-defunct Corinthian Colleges. The government canceled $5.8 billion, in the Department for Education’s largest single loan discharge.

A widespread cancellation would result in a higher price. A $10,000 forgiveness per borrower would cancel a total of $321 billion in debt, according to an April analysis by New York Fed researchers. A cancellation of $10,000 would extinguish the debts of 11.8 million borrowers, according to the researchers. It would also end obligations of 30.5% of student loans past due or in default before the payment break, according to the analysis.

Opponents say the pardon is an unfair bailout and a Pandora’s box opening up questions about who else should or shouldn’t get debt relief.

Last year, median student loan debt hovered between $20,000 and $24,999, according to a Federal Reserve study released in May. (Findings on household economic well-being were based on a fall survey of more than 11,000 people.)

Make no mistake, student loan forgiveness by any method or amount is a divisive idea.

Proponents say borrowers are in dire need of relief from a crisis linked to soaring education costs that have stifled too many family budgets. Opponents say it’s an unfair bailout and a Pandora’s box opening up questions about who else should or shouldn’t get debt relief.

There are winners and losers in this debate. Love it or hate it, if a cancellation happens, the financial landscape for millions is about to change. It can change them completely, or it can be “a drop in the bucket”.

Here’s a guide to these potential changes and the best ways to deal with what might happen next:

Household budgets

Financial planner Savon Gibson has previously talked to his clients about what would happen to their budgets if $10,000 in federal student loan debt were forgiven. It’s about identifying the “next biggest debt” or “next biggest priority,” where the suddenly freed up money can go, said Gibson, owner and managing director of Gibson Financial Planning in Cincinnati, Ohio.

To be clear, Gibson warns customers against the possibility of cancellation. But if that happens, he wants them already thinking about their next move.

Many Gibson customers have between $20,000 and $40,000 in student loans, so $10,000 of relief would be “substantial.” About 20% of Gibson’s customer base has set aside money for student loan payments, while many more have applied potential payment money elsewhere.

Freeing up $10,000 could allow people to build emergency savings or pay off high-interest debt like a credit card.

If the cancellation happens, Gibson said the budgetary question becomes “where will the funds have the most impact?” There isn’t just one answer. That could involve building up emergency savings or paying off higher-interest debt, like a credit card, at a faster pace as interest rates rise, Gibson noted.

For people who have money set aside — and are likely already keen to pay off debt and save — Gibson said they could put the lump sum towards long-term goals, like retirement accounts. or additional mortgage payments.

About seven in 10 borrowers making regular payments before the pandemic pause say they can afford to resume payments, according to a Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia survey released in May.

But 92% of employed borrowers feared they could restart payments in times of high inflation, according to a February survey by the Student Debt Crisis Center, an advocacy group.

Credit scores

Credit scores still matter. But in an era of rising interest rates intended to counter inflation, “maintaining a healthy credit score is especially important,” said Bruce McClary, spokesman for the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, an organization non-profit financial advisor. Lower scores mean even higher borrowing costs, and that’s the last thing anyone needs when so many other prices are rising, he explained.

Credit scores are meant to give insight into a person’s reliability in paying off debt, but McClary said he’s uncertain whether suddenly having less student loan debt automatically leads to better rating.

Of course, a $10,000 discount “could trigger events and circumstances leading to higher scores.” This would happen, for example, if money otherwise intended for student loans could now be allocated to high credit card balances.

Financial advisers warn that it is uncertain whether suddenly having less student loan debt would lead to a higher credit score.

“Ultimately, it would improve their debt-to-equity ratio and help boost their credit score as those credit card balances go down,” McClary said.

“Given the uncertainties, it is too early to tell how individual consumer credit would be affected,” said Margaret Poe, consumer credit education manager at TransUnion TRU,
one of the top three credit reporting companies.

Scores are created with factors such as “payment history, your balances or how much you owe, the age of your credit history, new credit, and the different types of credit you have, also known as of your credit mix,” Poe said. Plus, the ratio of your debt to your credit limit.

When someone has student loans, “it adds to your credit mix, which can improve your score over time. Making payments on time can also help establish healthy credit. However, if you repay and close a student loan, your credit mix may become less diverse, which could lower your score,” Poe said.

Still, she added, “paying off all student debt as efficiently as possible is a smart move for your financial health.”


Typically, canceled debts stifle repayment obligations to the lender, but they trigger tax obligations to the Internal Revenue Service. This is because the IRS generally considers the amount of canceled debt as income.

Still, borrowers will avoid a coming tax surprise if Biden goes ahead with the pardon, experts say. They might just need to allow for additional state income taxes depending on where they live.

Exceptions to the tax code already exist for student loan forgiveness. For example, people whose student loans are forgiven through the Civil Service Loan Forgiveness Program, such as teachers and nurses, are not subject to additional federal taxes for their forgiven debts.

Until recently, the waiver of debt tax exceptions generally did not apply to borrowers, said Matthew Chingos, vice president of education data and policy at the Urban Institute, a group left reflection.

The U.S. bailout exempted student loan forgiveness from paying federal tax on that forgiveness until 2026.

The March 2021 U.S. bailout changed that, exempting student loan cancellation from federal debt tax cancellation provisions until 2026. canceled loans and prevented student loan debt from becoming tax debt, Chingos said. “The purpose of this change was to take this issue off the table,” he said.

It makes no difference for tax purposes whether student loan debt is forgiven by executive action or a change in congressional law, Chingos said. Without the tax provisions, a borrower earning at least $122,000 a year would have faced an additional $2,400 in federal taxes, according to Chingos research. A person earning less than $25,000 a year would have had to pay an additional $800 in federal income tax, according to the calculations.

But borrowers in some places may have to pay state-level income taxes for debt forgiveness, according to Susan Allen, senior tax practices and ethics officer at the American Institute of CPAs.

The tax laws of about 20 states would follow federal law with respect to the tax treatment of student debt forgiveness, Allen said. Connecticut and Maryland are two examples. But the tax laws of about 15 states, including New Jersey and Mississippi, have potentially open questions on the issue, she added.

This is where it’s important to do your homework or check with a tax professional to see if the reversal happens, Allen said. “Each state would have different nuances to check.”

About Joan Dow

Check Also

Want to see Taylor Swift on tour? You might need a Capital One credit card

Image source: Getty Images If you want to see Taylor Swift in 2023, you’ll need …